Didier Verna <verna(a)inf.enst.fr> writes:
> It doesn't contain the simplest reference to the message that
> produced the error. Not even a reminder of the subject line or
> something.
OK, now we at least have something to work with. I'll ask Kyle to
include such references in the message.
> > > I'm a member of this list, and I know `wonderworks', so it's
> > > ok. However, I honestly think that if I were an occasionnal patch
> > > sender, receiving back this kind of /very friendly/ message would
>
> ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ JIC, that was ironic.
I know.
> > > probably discourage me from contributing anymore :-/
> >
> > Now I don't understand what you're talking about. Did you have a
> > bad day, or am I missing something really basic?
>
> No I didn't have a bad day. I just hate anonymity. This message is
> indeed very polite, but you can perfectly tell somebody to get lost
> with very polite terms. To me, the sentence "if your message doesn't
> contain a patch, it will be discarded" sounds like politely telling
> the guy that we don't give a damn to what he says appart from diff
> -u.
Didier, for heaven's sake! Just *how* did you get this impression?
When one is posting to a patches-only no-discussion mailing list, why
should it be so strange that the robot moderator rejects the message?
In the first incarnation, the robot would reject the message with _no_
feedback. This is much better, so we *do* give a damn what he says
apart from diff -u.
> There could be a more friendly message instead, like "This list is
> for patches only. If your message contains a bug report or general
> comments on xemacs, please try xemacs-beta", but not just "You
> lost. Try again."
I'll ask Kyle to implement this.
> There might be a cultural difference here. Maybe it's the
> frogs. Maybe it's just me. Oh well, maybe I'm having a bad day,
> after all :-)
I vote for bad day. :-)
--
Hrvoje Niksic <hniksic(a)srce.hr> | Student at FER Zagreb, Croatia
--------------------------------+--------------------------------
* Q: What is an experienced Emacs user?
* A: A person who wishes that the terminal had pedals.