5:38 p.m.
Stephen's recent upload of changes to the INSTALL file prompted me to
read the file for the first time in years.
I have made some corrections (to minor word forms and version numbers)
in the new INSTALL file. The patch is included for INSTALL and
CHANGELOG. I read one section where more detail would help, but I do
not know the detail to add. In "Specifying Location of Headers and
Libraries" the --with-site-runtime-libraries explanation states that
multiple directories can be added to the search path; however, it does
not specify the format of that list. The paragraph above it for
--with-site-includes specifies the format for its directory list. The
formats for directory search paths accepted by the configure procedure
either require colon-delimited, comma-delimited, or space-delimited
lists (the latter enclosed within quotation marks) as stated in other
sections of the INSTALL file. It is not clear how to format the
--with-site-runtime-libraries list of directories based on the
paragraph in this section.
In the section "Advanced Make" the default for datadir is listed as
/usr/local/data. This does not seem to be correct on all systems.
Earlier in INSTALL, the directories listed here as being part of the
installation defaulted to PREFIX/share/xemacs-VERSION rather than to
PREFIX/data/xemacs-VERSION. On my system where PREFIX=~/usr/local, I
have ~/usr/local/share/xemacs-21.5.b32/ with etc, lisp, and info as
child directories. Should `data' in `/usr/local/data' be changed to
`share'? Note, that in later references to datadir, /usr/local/share
is referenced as the default directory. I included this in the patch.
I cahnged one "can not" to "cannot" to match other uses in the
document.
I changed references to version numbers at various places in the file
in attempt to show only the latest stable and the latest beta. I did
this because other examples of directories created with the version
name had already been updated.
Consider whether the section "Selecting configure Options" should
include a forward reference to "Appendix: Correspondence to Old
configure Options." The list of removed options and enable/with
modifiers could be useful. I suggest moving the last paragraph of
"Random Notes" into the "Selecting configure Options" section.
I am not certain of the style for some nomenclature. I cannot tell
whether the document should always to refer to the file `configure' in
all lower case or to let that float. In some titles the style is to
use all caps for CONFIGURE when it appears to be a reference to the
file, but in others it is configure (lc), and in one it is Configure
(using title case).
_______________________________________________
XEmacs-Beta mailing list
XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org
http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta
8:17 p.m.
On Thu, 27 Dec 2012 12:38:43 -0500
Robert Royar <xemacs(a)royar.org> wrote:
In the section "Advanced Make" the default for datadir is
listed as
/usr/local/data. This does not seem to be correct on all systems.
Earlier in INSTALL, the directories listed here as being part of the
installation defaulted to PREFIX/share/xemacs-VERSION rather than to
PREFIX/data/xemacs-VERSION. On my system where PREFIX=~/usr/local, I
have ~/usr/local/share/xemacs-21.5.b32/ with etc, lisp, and info as
child directories. Should `data' in `/usr/local/data' be changed to
`share'? Note, that in later references to datadir, /usr/local/share
is referenced as the default directory. I included this in the patch.
In 21.4 the default location is PREFIX/data. In 21.5 this has been
changed to PREFIX/share. IMHO it should stay as data until 21.5 is
released.
Cheers,
Sean
_______________________________________________
XEmacs-Beta mailing list
XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org
http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta
1:26 a.m.
Sean MacLennan writes:
In 21.4 the default location is PREFIX/data. In 21.5 this has been
changed to PREFIX/share. IMHO it should stay as data until 21.5 is
released.
Nice catch, but not relevant. INSTALL is version-specific.
The info docs on the website are another matter, of course. I'm not
sure what to do about that; they are 21.5-specific.
_______________________________________________
XEmacs-Beta mailing list
XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org
http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta
3:47 a.m.
New subject: [AC21.5] New INSTALL file
APPROVE COMMIT 21.5
Robert Royar writes:
I have made some corrections (to minor word forms and version
numbers)
in the new INSTALL file. The patch is included for INSTALL and
CHANGELOG.
Thank you, Robert! I didn't actually read much past the section
titles. ;-)
I read one section where more detail would help, but I do
not know the detail to add. In "Specifying Location of Headers and
Libraries" the --with-site-runtime-libraries explanation states that
multiple directories can be added to the search path; however, it does
not specify the format of that list.
As you guessed, the same code is used for processing all these lists.
I added a paragraph to that effect.
In the section "Advanced Make" the default for datadir is
listed as
/usr/local/data. This does not seem to be correct on all systems.
As Sean pointed out, this is a 21.5 improvement (ie, FHS compatibility).
I changed references to version numbers at various places in the file
Good idea. I fixed the syntax of betas (21.5-b32) and added the
patchlevel for the stable line.
Consider whether the section "Selecting configure Options"
should
include a forward reference to "Appendix: Correspondence to Old
configure Options." The list of removed options and enable/with
modifiers could be useful. I suggest moving the last paragraph of
"Random Notes" into the "Selecting configure Options" section.
Postponed to issue849.
I am not certain of the style for some nomenclature. I cannot tell
whether the document should always to refer to the file `configure' in
all lower case or to let that float.
I put section titles in upper case, text uses in lower case, and
references to section titles in title case.
# HG changeset patch
# Parent 6b027725e3401176451d62ba5e86de32bc38c6d6
More corrections to INSTALL by Robert Royer.
diff -r 6b027725e340 -r 37b107e878b8 ChangeLog
--- a/ChangeLog Fri Dec 28 02:29:16 2012 +0900
+++ b/ChangeLog Fri Dec 28 12:35:44 2012 +0900
＠＠ -1,3 +1,13 ＠＠
+2012-12-27 Robert D. Royar <xemacs(a)royar.org>
+
+ Minor additions by Stephen J. Turnbull <stephen(a)xemacs.org>.
+
+ * INSTALL: correct typographical errors; update
+ version numbers provided in Running Make section;
+ change default datadir reference to /usr/local/share
+ to match all other references to datadir's subdirectories;
+ change "can not" to "cannot".
+
2012-11-04 Stephen J. Turnbull <stephen(a)xemacs.org>
* INSTALL: Reorganize and update.
diff -r 6b027725e340 -r 37b107e878b8 INSTALL
--- a/INSTALL Fri Dec 28 02:29:16 2012 +0900
+++ b/INSTALL Fri Dec 28 12:35:44 2012 +0900
＠＠ -28,8 +28,8 ＠＠
Modern systems generally have more than enough RAM and virtual memory to run
XEmacs well. If you run into an "insufficient memory" error when building
-or on the first execution, see the 'PROBLEMS' file. In sufficient stack
-space is a separate problem, also address in 'PROBLEMS'.
+or on the first execution, see the 'PROBLEMS' file. Insufficient stack
+space is a separate problem, also addressed in 'PROBLEMS'.
Building XEmacs requires about 100 Mb of disk space (including the XEmacs
sources). Once installed, XEmacs occupies about 200 MB in the file system
＠＠ -136,7 +136,7 ＠＠
doesn't seem to have all the corresponding features, check with the newsgroup
'comp.emacs.xemacs' or the mailing list 'xemacs-beta(a)xemacs.org'.
-SELECTING configure OPTIONS
+SELECTING CONFIGURE OPTIONS
===========================
Options are generally of the form `--with-FEATURE' to use a feature or
＠＠ -402,7 +402,7 ＠＠
`/usr/local/share/xemacs-VERSION/lisp' holds the basic Emacs Lisp libraries
(including core implementations of many Lisp primitives);
`VERSION' stands for the number of the XEmacs version
- you are installing, like `19.14' or `21.5.31'. Since
+ you are installing, like `21.4.22' or `21.5-b32'. Since
the lisp libraries change from one version of XEmacs to
another, including the version number in the path
allows you to have several versions of XEmacs installed
＠＠ -500,7 +500,7 ＠＠
========
The most common problem is that you forgot to read and follow the directions
-for installing bootstrap packages in the FAQ. You can not have a normal
+for installing bootstrap packages in the FAQ. You cannot have a normal
XEmacs without downloading some additional packages.
See the file PROBLEMS in this directory for a list of various problems
＠＠ -760,17 +760,19 ＠＠
`datadir' indicates where to put the architecture-independent
read-only data files that XEmacs refers to while it runs; it
- defaults to /usr/local/data. We create the following
+ defaults to /usr/local/share. We create the following
subdirectories under `datadir':
+
- `xemacs-VERSION/lisp', containing the XEmacs lisp libraries, and
- `xemacs-VERSION/etc', containing the XEmacs tutorial and the
`yow' database.
+
`VERSION' is the number of the XEmacs version you are installing,
- like `18.59' or `19.14'. Since these files vary from one version
- of XEmacs to another, including the version number in the path
- allows you to have several versions of XEmacs installed at the
- same time; this means that you don't have to make XEmacs
+ like `21.4.22' or `21.5-b32'. Since these files vary from one
+ version of XEmacs to another, including the version number in the
+ path allows you to have several versions of XEmacs installed at
+ the same time; this means that you don't have to make XEmacs
unavailable while installing a new version.
`datarootdir' indicates where to put the documentation. (Usually,
＠＠ -884,7 +886,7 ＠＠
in the subdirectories.
Using GNU Make allows for simultaneous builds with and without the --srcdir
-option.
+option (see the section Running Configure).
MAIL LOCKING
============
＠＠ -1177,6 +1179,10 ＠＠
configuration changes. Not all systems need this option; it's best to avoid
using it if you can.
+To specify multiple directories in these commands, use a list delimited by
+spaces, colons, or commas. You will need to protect space-delimited lists
+from shell parsing by quoting them.
+
If you haven't built XEmacs 21.5 recently, the change from the configure
script based on Autoconf 2.13 can be a shock. Appendix: Correspondence to
Old Configure Options (at the end of this document) contains a list of old
_______________________________________________
XEmacs-Beta mailing list
XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org
http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta
4130
days inactive
4131
days old
3 comments
3 participants
participants (3)
-
Robert Royar -
Sean MacLennan -
Stephen J. Turnbull