KIRIYAMA Kazuhiko writes: The error messages you provide are insufficient to diagnose the problem. At a minimum, we need to know which file is failing to compile. Normally each file's compilation process is reported quite verbosely IIRC, but I don't see that. Are there any .elcs in the build lisp/ directory? Also, this: Testing for Lisp shadows ... This site has duplicate Lisp libraries with the same name. If a locally-installed Lisp library overrides a library in the Emacs release, that can cause trouble, and you should probably remove the locally-installed version unless you know what you are doing. is quite possibly the source of your problem. _______________________________________________ XEmacs-Beta mailing list XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta

KIRIYAMA Kazuhiko writes: OK, so some of the .elcs have been compiled, but not all. I'm not sure why that is. OK, I think this is not a problem, after looking more closely at the shadows. Why do you think they are needed? You should be able to bootstrap XEmacs with gcc and binutils, and any system headers and libraries you want to link. You should not need any packages installed. It appears that your XEmacs thinks it needs kana-keyboard.el, which is in the mule-base package, to run. I don't understand why; grepping our 21.4 sources shows no references to that library. The reason the installed package is not found on your system is the -no-autoloads option in the build script (which is correct, it helps to prevent shadowing problems). I suspect this reference to code not included in the base XEmacs distribution has something to do with non-XEmacs patches to your port, but it's hard to say for sure. Try "strings ./xemacs | grep kana-keyboard". If it doesn't show up there, I'm not sure offhand what to say. I'm going to be traveling for the next 4 days, and most likely unable to read mail. _______________________________________________ XEmacs-Beta mailing list XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta

KIRIYAMA Kazuhiko, When I am having weird lisp build problems with non-mule builds I always make sure there are no mule elcs left lying around. I think this is more a problem for 21.5 though. So, after untarring the xemacs source, but before starting to build, cd to the source and do something like: find . -name \*.elc -delete The make will always recompile all the lisp files for you... it doesn't even take that long. Cheers, Sean _______________________________________________ XEmacs-Beta mailing list XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta

At Sun, 1 May 2016 19:13:57 +0900, Stephen J. Turnbull wrote: I dont know why, but anyway src/xemacs binary wants any *.elc in mule-base package. Without -no-autoloads option, passed building lisp stage in lisp directory: root＠desktop:/usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24 # ./src/xemacs -batch -l autoload -f batch-update-directory lisp Loading cl-macs... Updating autoloads in directory /usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24/lisp... Generating autoloads for lisp/abbrev.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/about.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/alist.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/apropos.el... No autoloads found in lisp/auto-save.el No autoloads found in lisp/auto-show.el Generating autoloads for lisp/autoload.el... No autoloads found in lisp/backquote.el No autoloads found in lisp/blessmail.el Generating autoloads for lisp/buff-menu.el... No autoloads found in lisp/buffer.el Generating autoloads for lisp/build-report.el... No autoloads found in lisp/byte-optimize.el No autoloads found in lisp/bytecomp-runtime.el Generating autoloads for lisp/bytecomp.el... No autoloads found in lisp/callers-of-rpt.el No autoloads found in lisp/check-features.el No autoloads found in lisp/cl-compat.el No autoloads found in lisp/cl-extra.el Generating autoloads for lisp/cl-macs.el... No autoloads found in lisp/cl-seq.el No autoloads found in lisp/cl.el No autoloads found in lisp/cmdloop.el No autoloads found in lisp/code-cmds.el No autoloads found in lisp/code-files.el No autoloads found in lisp/code-process.el No autoloads found in lisp/coding.el No autoloads found in lisp/compat.el Generating autoloads for lisp/config.el... No autoloads found in lisp/console.el Generating autoloads for lisp/cus-dep.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/cus-edit.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/cus-face.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/cus-file.el... No autoloads found in lisp/cus-load.el No autoloads found in lisp/cus-start.el No autoloads found in lisp/custom-load.el No autoloads found in lisp/custom.el No autoloads found in lisp/derived.el No autoloads found in lisp/device.el No autoloads found in lisp/dialog-gtk.el No autoloads found in lisp/dialog-items.el No autoloads found in lisp/dialog.el Generating autoloads for lisp/disass.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/disp-table.el... No autoloads found in lisp/dragdrop.el No autoloads found in lisp/dump-paths.el No autoloads found in lisp/dumped-lisp.el No autoloads found in lisp/easy-mmode.el Generating autoloads for lisp/easymenu.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/etags.el... No autoloads found in lisp/events.el No autoloads found in lisp/extents.el No autoloads found in lisp/faces.el No autoloads found in lisp/files-nomule.el No autoloads found in lisp/files.el No autoloads found in lisp/fill.el No autoloads found in lisp/find-paths.el No autoloads found in lisp/finder-inf.el Generating autoloads for lisp/finder.el... No autoloads found in lisp/float-sup.el Generating autoloads for lisp/font-lock.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/font-menu.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/font.el... No autoloads found in lisp/fontl-hooks.el No autoloads found in lisp/format.el No autoloads found in lisp/frame.el No autoloads found in lisp/gdk.el No autoloads found in lisp/generic-widgets.el No autoloads found in lisp/glade.el No autoloads found in lisp/glyphs.el No autoloads found in lisp/gnome-widgets.el No autoloads found in lisp/gnome.el Generating autoloads for lisp/gnuserv.el... No autoloads found in lisp/gpm.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-compose.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-extra.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-faces.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-ffi.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-file-dialog.el Generating autoloads for lisp/gtk-font-menu.el... No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-glyphs.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-init.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-iso8859-1.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-marshal.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-mouse.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-package.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-password-dialog.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-select.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-widget-accessors.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk-widgets.el No autoloads found in lisp/gtk.el No autoloads found in lisp/gui.el No autoloads found in lisp/gutter-items.el No autoloads found in lisp/gutter.el Generating autoloads for lisp/help-macro.el... No autoloads found in lisp/help-nomule.el No autoloads found in lisp/help.el Generating autoloads for lisp/hyper-apropos.el... No autoloads found in lisp/indent.el Generating autoloads for lisp/info.el... No autoloads found in lisp/isearch-mode.el No autoloads found in lisp/iso8859-1.el Generating autoloads for lisp/itimer-autosave.el... No autoloads found in lisp/itimer.el No autoloads found in lisp/keydefs.el No autoloads found in lisp/keymap.el No autoloads found in lisp/ldap.el No autoloads found in lisp/lib-complete.el No autoloads found in lisp/lisp-mnt.el No autoloads found in lisp/lisp-mode.el No autoloads found in lisp/lisp.el No autoloads found in lisp/list-mode.el Generating autoloads for lisp/loaddefs.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/loadhist.el... No autoloads found in lisp/loadup-el.el No autoloads found in lisp/loadup.el No autoloads found in lisp/make-docfile.el No autoloads found in lisp/map-ynp.el No autoloads found in lisp/menubar-items.el No autoloads found in lisp/menubar.el No autoloads found in lisp/minibuf.el No autoloads found in lisp/misc.el No autoloads found in lisp/mode-motion.el No autoloads found in lisp/modeline.el No autoloads found in lisp/mouse.el No autoloads found in lisp/movemail.el No autoloads found in lisp/msw-faces.el Generating autoloads for lisp/msw-font-menu.el... No autoloads found in lisp/msw-glyphs.el No autoloads found in lisp/msw-init.el No autoloads found in lisp/msw-mouse.el No autoloads found in lisp/msw-select.el No autoloads found in lisp/multicast.el Generating autoloads for lisp/mwheel.el... No autoloads found in lisp/objects.el No autoloads found in lisp/obsolete.el Generating autoloads for lisp/package-admin.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/package-get.el... No autoloads found in lisp/package-info.el Generating autoloads for lisp/package-net.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/package-ui.el... No autoloads found in lisp/packages.el No autoloads found in lisp/page.el No autoloads found in lisp/paragraphs.el No autoloads found in lisp/paths.el Generating autoloads for lisp/picture.el... No autoloads found in lisp/printer.el No autoloads found in lisp/process.el Generating autoloads for lisp/rect.el... No autoloads found in lisp/register.el No autoloads found in lisp/replace.el No autoloads found in lisp/scrollbar.el No autoloads found in lisp/select.el No autoloads found in lisp/setup-paths.el Generating autoloads for lisp/shadow.el... No autoloads found in lisp/simple.el No autoloads found in lisp/site-load.el Generating autoloads for lisp/sound.el... No autoloads found in lisp/specifier.el No autoloads found in lisp/startup.el No autoloads found in lisp/subr.el No autoloads found in lisp/symbol-syntax.el No autoloads found in lisp/symbols.el No autoloads found in lisp/syntax.el No autoloads found in lisp/text-mode.el No autoloads found in lisp/text-props.el No autoloads found in lisp/toolbar-items.el No autoloads found in lisp/toolbar.el No autoloads found in lisp/tty-init.el No autoloads found in lisp/undo-stack.el No autoloads found in lisp/update-elc-2.el No autoloads found in lisp/update-elc.el Generating autoloads for lisp/userlock.el... No autoloads found in lisp/version.el No autoloads found in lisp/very-early-lisp.el Generating autoloads for lisp/view-less.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/wid-browse.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/wid-edit.el... No autoloads found in lisp/widget.el No autoloads found in lisp/widgets-gtk.el No autoloads found in lisp/win32-native.el No autoloads found in lisp/window-xemacs.el No autoloads found in lisp/window.el No autoloads found in lisp/x-compose.el No autoloads found in lisp/x-faces.el Generating autoloads for lisp/x-font-menu.el... No autoloads found in lisp/x-init.el No autoloads found in lisp/x-iso8859-1.el No autoloads found in lisp/x-misc.el No autoloads found in lisp/x-mouse.el No autoloads found in lisp/x-scrollbar.el No autoloads found in lisp/x-select.el Generating autoloads for lisp/x-win-sun.el... Generating autoloads for lisp/x-win-xfree86.el... Saving file /usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24/lisp/auto-autoloads.el... Wrote /usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24/lisp/auto-autoloads.el Wrote /usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24/lisp/auto-autoloads.el root＠desktop:/usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24 # I refer in lisp/*.el and lisp/*.elc, the results as follows: root＠desktop:/usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24 # find ./lisp -name '*.el' -type f -exec basename \{} .el \; | sort | uniq > /var/tmp/lisp_el.list root＠desktop:/usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24 # find ./lisp -name '*.elc' -type f -exec basename \{} .elc \; | sort | uniq > /var/tmp/lisp_elc.list root＠desktop:/usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24 # diff -u /var/tmp/lisp_el.list /var/tmp/lisp_elc.list --- /var/tmp/lisp_el.list 2016-05-03 12:09:53.940130000 +0900 +++ /var/tmp/lisp_elc.list 2016-05-03 12:10:15.653743000 +0900 ＠＠ -1,119 +1,54 ＠＠ abbrev -about -alist -apollo -apropos arabic -AT386 auto-autoloads auto-save auto-show -autoload backquote -bg-mouse -blessmail -bobcat buff-menu buffer -build-report -byte-optimize bytecomp bytecomp-runtime -callers-of-rpt -canna-leim -check-features chinese cl -cl-compat cl-extra -cl-macs cl-seq cmdloop code-cmds code-files code-process coding -compat -config console -cus-dep -cus-edit -cus-face cus-file -cus-load cus-start custom -custom-load cyrillic derived device dialog -dialog-gtk dialog-items -disass -disp-table -dragdrop dump-paths -dumped-lisp -easy-mmode easymenu english -etags ethiopic european events extents faces files -files-nomule fill find-paths -finder -finder-inf float-sup -font -font-lock -font-menu fontl-hooks format frame -gdk -generic-widgets -glade glyphs -gnome -gnome-widgets -gnuserv -gpm greek -gtk -gtk-compose -gtk-extra -gtk-faces -gtk-ffi -gtk-file-dialog -gtk-font-menu -gtk-glyphs -gtk-init -gtk-iso8859-1 -gtk-marshal -gtk-mouse -gtk-package -gtk-password-dialog -gtk-select -gtk-widget-accessors -gtk-widgets gui gutter gutter-items hebrew help -help-macro -help-nomule -hyper-apropos indent -info -internal isearch-mode iso8859-1 itimer ＠＠ -121,23 +56,15 ＠＠ japanese keydefs keymap -keyswap kinsoku korean latin -ldap lib-complete -linux lisp -lisp-mnt lisp-mode list-mode -lk201 loaddefs loadhist -loadup -loadup-el -make-docfile map-ynp menubar menubar-items ＠＠ -148,12 +75,6 ＠＠ modeline mouse movemail -msw-faces -msw-font-menu -msw-glyphs -msw-init -msw-mouse -msw-select mule-category mule-ccl mule-charset ＠＠ -165,42 +86,23 ＠＠ mule-tty-init mule-x-init multicast -mwheel -news objects obsolete -package-admin -package-get -package-info -package-net -package-ui packages page paragraphs paths -pc-win -picture printer process -rect register replace -scoansi scrollbar select setup-paths -shadow simple -site-load -sound specifier startup subr -sun -sun-mouse -sup-mouse -symbol-syntax -symbols syntax text-mode text-props ＠＠ -209,41 +111,14 ＠＠ toolbar toolbar-items tty-init -tvi970 undo-stack -update-elc -update-elc-2 -userlock version -very-early-lisp viet-chars vietnamese -view-less -vt-control -vt100 -vt100-led -vt102 -vt125 -vt200 -vt201 -vt220 -vt240 -vt300 -vt320 -vt400 -vt420 -wid-browse -wid-edit widget -widgets-gtk -win32-native -win32-win window window-xemacs -wyse50 -x-compose x-faces -x-font-menu x-init x-iso8859-1 x-misc ＠＠ -252,4 +127,3 ＠＠ x-select x-win-sun x-win-xfree86 -xterm root＠desktop:/usr/portbuild/var/ports/homekxj/editors/xemacs/work/xemacs-21.4.24 # IMHO, there are all *.el in lisp directory that allow all options of configure. In fact, those include *.els with which I don't specified in configure arguments. So xemacs could not autoload those *.els. Is this wrong? --- KIRIYAMA Kazuhiko _______________________________________________ XEmacs-Beta mailing list XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta

Welcome home!, Stephen At Fri, 6 May 2016 17:53:54 +0900, Stephen J. Turnbull wrote: All you've pointed out were right! I've made latest prune FreeBSD 11.0-CURRENT(r298951) and `make build' then there is nothing to stop or hung up. And `make install', `make package', `pkg delete -yf xemacs-21.4.24_6' and `pkg add /var/ports/packages/All/xemacs-21.4.24_6.txz' are perfectly done:-) I'm ready to commit xepkg ports schime, and re-porting xemacs back to FreeBSD ports tree. When everything done, before send-pr to bugzilla of FreeBSD, I'll tell you what about xemacs usage on FreeBSD with my xepkg ports schime. Thanks for your courteous reply of my messy reports. Best Regards --- KIRIYAMA Kazuhiko _______________________________________________ XEmacs-Beta mailing list XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org http://lists.xemacs.org/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta