9:42 p.m.
This bug report will be sent to the XEmacs Development Team,
not to your local site managers!!
Please write in English, because the XEmacs maintainers do not have
translators to read other languages for them.
Please describe as succinctly as possible:
- What happened.
- What you thought should have happened.
- Precisely what you were doing at the time.
Please also include any C or lisp back-traces that you may have.
================================================================
Dear Bug Team!
I am running XEmacs 21.4.4 with all the latest packages, and find that
in Gnus to make the "o" (Save article) command work, I need to have
apel and tm installed. In particular, the comment in the package list
for tm says that Gnus >= 5.8.0 doesn't need it. I have Gnus 5.8.8, and
in order to save articles I need tm. tm in turn needs apel.
================================================================
System Info to help track down your bug:
---------------------------------------
uname -a: Linux msrc-v-reubth.europe.corp.microsoft.com 2.4.3-12 #1 Fri Jun 8 15:05:56 EDT
2001 i686 unknown
./configure '--prefix=/home/rrt' '--with-mule'
XEmacs 21.4.4 "Artificial Intelligence" configured for `i686-pc-linux'.
Compilation / Installation:
Source code location: /home/rrt/xemacs-21.4.4
Installation prefix: /home/rrt
Operating system description file: `s/linux.h'
Machine description file: `m/intel386.h'
Compiler: gcc -g -O3 -Wall -Wno-switch -Winline
-Wmissing-prototypes -Wshadow -Wsign-compare
Relocating allocator for buffers: no
GNU version of malloc: yes
- Using Doug Lea's new malloc from the GNU C Library.
Window System:
Compiling in support for the X window system:
- X Windows headers location: /usr/X11R6/include
- X Windows libraries location: /usr/X11R6/lib
- Handling WM_COMMAND properly.
Using Lucid menubars.
Using Lucid scrollbars.
TTY:
Compiling in support for ncurses.
Compiling in support for GPM (General Purpose Mouse).
Images:
Compiling in support for GIF images (builtin).
Compiling in support for XPM images.
Compiling in support for PNG images.
Compiling in support for JPEG images.
Compiling in support for TIFF images.
Sound:
Compiling in support for sound (native).
Databases:
Compiling in support for Berkeley database.
Compiling in support for LDAP.
Internationalization:
Compiling in support for Mule (multi-lingual Emacs).
Compiling in support for XIM (X11R5+ I18N input method).
- Using raw Xlib to provide XIM support.
Mail:
Compiling in support for "dot-locking" mail spool file locking method.
Other Features:
Compiling in support for dynamic shared object modules.
Load-Path Lisp Shadows:
----------------------
(/home/rrt/elisp/vm-mime
/home/rrt/lib/xemacs/xemacs-packages/lisp/vm/vm-mime)
Installed XEmacs Packages:
-------------------------
((zenirc:version 1.11 :type regular)
(xslt-process :version 1.05 :type regular)
(xemacs-devel :version 1.39 :type single-file)
(xemacs-base :version 1.56 :type regular)
(w3 :version 1.2 :type regular)
(vm :version 7.0 :type regular)
(view-process :version 1.11 :type regular)
(vc :version 1.3 :type regular)
(tm :version 1.29 :type regular)
(time :version 1.11 :type regular)
(textools :version 1.12 :type regular)
(text-modes :version 1.32 :type single-file)
(texinfo :version 1.2 :type regular)
(supercite :version 1.18 :type regular)
(speedbar :version 1.21 :type regular)
(slider :version 1.13 :type regular)
(sh-script :version 1.13 :type regular)
(sgml :version 1.08 :type regular)
(scheme :version 1.11 :type regular)
(rmail :version 1.12 :type regular)
(reftex :version 1.23 :type regular)
(psgml :version 1.25 :type regular)
(prog-modes
:version
1
.48
:type
single-file)
(pcomplete :version 1.01 :type regular)
(pcl-cvs :version 1.56 :type regular)
(pc :version 1.2 :type single-file)
(os-utils :version 1.25 :type single-file)
(net-utils :version 1.23 :type single-file)
(misc-games :version 1.15 :type single-file)
(mine :version 1.14 :type regular)
(mew :version 1.14 :type regular)
(mailcrypt :version 2.09 :type regular)
(mail-lib :version 1.4 :type regular)
(ispell :version 1.23 :type regular)
(igrep :version 1.08 :type regular)
(hm--html-menus :version 1.16 :type regular)
(gnus :version 1.57 :type regular)
(gnats :version 1.12 :type regular)
(games :version 1.13 :type regular)
(fsf-compat :version 1.09 :type single-file)
(frame-icon :version 1.09 :type regular)
(footnote :version 1.13 :type regular)
(eudc :version 1.34 :type regular)
(eterm :version 1.13 :type regular)
(eshell :version 1.01 :type regular)
(emerge :version 1.09 :type regular)
(elib :version 1.08 :type single-file)
(eieio :version 1.01 :type regular)
(eicq :version 1.05 :type regular)
(efs :version 1.26 :type regular)
(edit-utils :version 1.73 :type single-file)
(ediff :version 1.33 :type regular)
(edebug :version 1.14 :type regular)
(dired :version 1.11 :type regular)
(dictionary :version 1.06 :type regular)
(debug :version 1.14 :type regular)
(cookie :version 1.13 :type regular)
(cc-mode :version 1.26 :type regular)
(calendar :version 1.18 :type regular)
(calc :version 1.17 :type regular)
(c-support :version 1.16 :type single-file)
(build :version 1.03 :type regular)
(bbdb :version 1.16 :type regular)
(auctex :version 1.28 :type regular)
(mule-ucs :version 1.0 :type regular)
(mule-base :version 1.39 :type regular)
(lookup :version 1.08 :type regular)
(leim :version 1.17 :type regular)
(egg-its :version 1.26 :type regular)
(edict :version 1.12 :type regular))
Features:
--------
(xemacsbug shadow gnus-async gnus-score score-mode gnus-ml gnus-msg
gnus-art mm-uu mm-view gnus-sum nndraft nnmh gnus-cache gnus-group
gnus-undo nnmail mail-source format-spec nntp nnoo gnus-start
gnus-range gnus-spec gnus-int gnus-win gnus gnus-ems gnus-xmas
vm-toolbar vm-motion vm-summary tapestry vm-menu vm-folder vm-misc
vm-mouse vm-window message mml mm-decode mm-encode mailcap mm-bodies
uudecode mail-parse rfc2045 rfc2231 rfc2047 gnus-util qp ietf-drums
time-date parse-time mail-abbrevs mailheader vm-grepmail mailcrypt
comint efs-cu bbdb-vm bbdb-snarf bbdb-com vm-pine sendmail rfc822
vm-macro vm-message vm-summary-faces smiley annotations messagexmas
nnheader nnheaderxm mm-util mail-prsvr mail-utils vm-autoload
highlight-headers vm-vars vm-version vm vm-startup font disp-table
blink-cursor permanent-buffers where-was-i-db lazy-shot font-lock
balloon-help avoid paren blink-paren after-save-commands advice
advice-preload env tex-site cc-styles cc-vars wid-edit cc-defs
filladapt ansi-color bbdb timezone sb-info info speedbar sb-image
dframe assoc find-files jka-compr vc ring vc-hooks mwheel edmacro
iswitchb gnuserv time cus-face zenirc-autoloads xslt-process-autoloads
xemacs-devel-autoloads xemacs-base-autoloads w3-autoloads vm-autoloads
view-process-autoloads vc-autoloads tm-autoloads time-autoloads
textools-autoloads text-modes-autoloads texinfo-autoloads
supercite-autoloads speedbar-autoloads slider-autoloads
sh-script-autoloads sgml-autoloads scheme-autoloads rmail-autoloads
reftex-autoloads psgml-autoloads prog-modes-autoloads
pcomplete-autoloads pcl-cvs-autoloads pc-autoloads os-utils-autoloads
net-utils-autoloads misc-games-autoloads mine-autoloads mew-autoloads
mailcrypt-autoloads mail-lib-autoloads ispell-autoloads
igrep-autoloads hm--html-menus-autoloads gnus-autoloads
gnats-autoloads games-autoloads fsf-compat-autoloads
frame-icon-autoloads footnote-autoloads eudc-autoloads eterm-autoloads
eshell-autoloads emerge-autoloads elib-autoloads eieio-autoloads
eicq-autoloads efs-autoloads edit-utils-autoloads ediff-autoloads
edebug-autoloads dired-autoloads dictionary-autoloads debug-autoloads
cookie-autoloads cc-mode-autoloads calendar-autoloads calc-autoloads
c-support-autoloads build-autoloads bbdb-autoloads auctex-autoloads
mule-ucs-autoloads mule-base-autoloads lookup-autoloads leim-autoloads
egg-its-autoloads edict-autoloads lisp-autoloads loadhist auto-show
fontl-hooks x-iso8859-1 slovenian czech romanian ccl mule-help
code-cmds gutter-items menubar-items x-menubar mode-motion mouse
itimer auto-save lisp-mode easymenu iso8859-1 page buff-menu
lib-complete cus-file derived frame text-props obsolete cus-start
custom widget cl-extra mini-cl cl cl-19 packages backquote
very-early-lisp file-coding mule lucid-scrollbars cut-buffer
lucid-menubars x c-balloon-help tty-frames tty toolbar native-sound
scrollbar unix-processes multicast network-streams subprocesses
modules menu-accelerator-support menubar berkeley-db md5 xemacs xim
gutter tiff png gif jpeg xpm xbm lisp-float-type linux devices
window-system base64)
Recent keystrokes:
-----------------
button1 button1up M-x v m RET g g g M-x g n SPC j u
s BS BS BS u s RET RET d d d d n n q M-x r e p o TAB
r TAB x e TAB RET
Recent messages (most recent first):
-----------------------------------
Loading xemacsbug...done
Loading xemacsbug...
Making completion list...
Saving /home/rrt/.newsrc.eld...done
Wrote /home/rrt/.newsrc.eld
Saving /home/rrt/.newsrc.eld...
Wrote /home/rrt/.newsrc
No more unread newsgroups
Loading gnus-async...done
Loading gnus-async...
No more unread articles (Type n to exit comp.emacs.xemacs)
No more articles
No more unread articles
Generating summary...done
Generating summary...
Loading gnus-score...done
Loading gnus-score...
Fetching headers for comp.emacs.xemacs...done
Fetching headers for comp.emacs.xemacs...
Loading gnus-ml...done
--
http://sc3d.org/rrt/ | Careful Cyclists Approaching From Right
10:53 p.m.
Reuben Thomas <rrt(a)sc3d.org> writes:
I am running XEmacs 21.4.4 with all the latest packages, and find
that
in Gnus to make the "o" (Save article) command work, I need to have
apel and tm installed. In particular, the comment in the package list
for tm says that Gnus >= 5.8.0 doesn't need it. I have Gnus 5.8.8, and
in order to save articles I need tm. tm in turn needs apel.
I don't think it should be needed. What made you believe that? Do
you got a backtrace or similar?
10:26 p.m.
This turned out to be interesting. Gnus uses RMAIL for saving
articles to files. But the RMAIL package in XEmacs requires TM and
APEL. I think Gnus is incompatible with TM and APEL.
Why do RMAIL requires TM/APEL?
Maybe the functions Gnus needs from RMAIL could be moved to mail-lib?
1:18 a.m.
On Sat, 05 Jan 2002, jas(a)extundo.com wrote:
This turned out to be interesting. Gnus uses RMAIL for saving
articles to files. But the RMAIL package in XEmacs requires TM and
APEL. I think Gnus is incompatible with TM and APEL.
Why do RMAIL requires TM/APEL?
Maybe the functions Gnus needs from RMAIL could be moved to
mail-lib?
While we're at it, vm winds up loading lots of files in APEL if you
convert a rmail file to vm. In particular poe.el in APEL redefines a
large number of functions, like require. If you have advised any of
the functions that poe.el redefines then it breaks badly. This is
because poe.el does stuff like
(fset 'si:require (symbol-function 'require))
Symbol-function does not return the real function definition if the
function has been advised. I was rather annoyed when I finally
tracked down this particular problem.
-jeff
4:17 a.m.
On Sat, 05 Jan 2002, jas(a)extundo.com wrote:
> This turned out to be interesting. Gnus uses RMAIL for saving
> articles to files. But the RMAIL package in XEmacs requires TM
> and APEL. I think Gnus is incompatible with TM and APEL.
> Why do RMAIL requires TM/APEL?
Because they're all three fundamentally broken together. APEL is a
basically good idea that is not sufficiently robustly implemented, and
TM depends on it, and RMAIL depends on TM for all MIME services.
Neither APEL nor TM can be effectively unloaded, either.
> Maybe the functions Gnus needs from RMAIL could be moved to
> mail-lib?
This might be a good idea, depending on whether we make any attempt to
keep RMAIL synched to GNU Emacs. It might also be possible to get rid
of the TM dependency in RMAIL if you're only moving whole messages
around, and don't need to parse MIME. That should get rid of the APEL
dependency. It would probably be easier to keep such an RMAIL synched.
>>>> "Jeff" == Jeff Mincy
<jeff(a)delphioutpost.com> writes:
Jeff> While we're at it, vm winds up loading lots of files in APEL
Jeff> if you convert a rmail file to vm. In particular poe.el in
Jeff> APEL redefines a large number of functions, like require.
Yup. Avoiding APEL is a really good idea.
Jeff> If you have advised any of the functions that poe.el
Jeff> redefines then it breaks badly.
Advising functions is generally not a good idea for this reason,
anyway.
Jeff> Symbol-function does not return the real function definition
Jeff> if the function has been advised. I was rather annoyed when
Jeff> I finally tracked down this particular problem.
I don't understand. Do you mean it returns the original definition
(wouldn't that be a bug in either symbol-function or advice?), or that
it returns the advised definition (what seems logical to me)?
--
Institute of Policy and Planning Sciences http://turnbull.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp
University of Tsukuba Tennodai 1-1-1 Tsukuba 305-8573 JAPAN
Don't ask how you can "do" free software business;
ask what your business can "do for" free software.
2:15 p.m.
On 07 Jan 2002, stephen(a)xemacs.org wrote:
>>>>> "Jeff" == Jeff Mincy
<jeff(a)delphioutpost.com> writes:
Jeff> While we're at it, vm winds up loading lots of files in
Jeff> APEL if you convert a rmail file to vm. In particular
Jeff> poe.el in APEL redefines a large number of functions, like
Jeff> require.
Yup. Avoiding APEL is a really good idea.
Jeff> If you have advised any of the functions that poe.el
Jeff> redefines then it breaks badly.
Advising functions is generally not a good idea for this reason,
anyway.
Advice is a generally less invasive way to make upward compatible
changes to functions. Advice has all kinds of bells & whistles for
controlling advised functions.
Jeff> Symbol-function does not return the real function
Jeff> definition if the function has been advised. I was rather
Jeff> annoyed when I finally tracked down this particular
Jeff> problem.
I don't understand. Do you mean it returns the original definition
(wouldn't that be a bug in either symbol-function or advice?), or
that it returns the advised definition (what seems logical to me)?
symbol-function just returns what is stored in the function slot.
This interacts badly when a function has been advised, but the
function is redefined without using advice.
Here is an example, with require renamed foo-require to protect the
innocent.
(defun foo-require (feature &optional filename)
(require feature filename))
(symbol-function 'foo-require)
;; returns->(lambda (feature &optional filename) (require feature filename))
(defadvice foo-require (around just-an-example first activate protect)
ad-do-it)
(symbol-function 'foo-require)
;; returns->#<compiled-function (feature &optional filename) "...(10)"
[nil ad-return-value ad-Orig-foo-require feature filename] 4 "$ad-doc:
foo-require$">
Stuff from poe.el, (again with require renamed)
(fset 'si:foo-require (symbol-function 'foo-require))
(put 'foo-require 'defun-maybe t)
(defun foo-require (feature &optional filename noerror)
(if noerror
(condition-case nil
(si:foo-require feature filename)
(file-error))
(si:foo-require feature filename)))
(symbol-function 'foo-require)
;; returns-> #<compiled-function (feature &optional filename noerror)
"...(11)" [nil ad-return-value ad-Orig-foo-require feature filename noerror] 5
"$ad-doc: foo-require$">
(foo-require 'font-lock)
;; Lisp nesting exceeds `max-lisp-eval-depth'
The problem here is that 'defun' notices that the function is advised,
and so redefines the original function. symbol-function gets the
advised function in the function slot of the symbol. The global
foo-require calls ad-Orig-foo-require, which calls the redefined
foo-require which calls si:foo-require, which is the advised function.
-jeff
2:26 a.m.
>>>> "Jeff" == Jeff Mincy
<jeff(a)delphioutpost.com> writes:
Jeff> Advice is a generally less invasive way to make upward
Jeff> compatible changes to functions. Advice has all kinds of
Jeff> bells & whistles for controlling advised functions.
I'm not contesting that; I'm saying that using a given piece of advice
over time is likely to break because people change the original
function out from under you.
You could argue that once a function has been defined, all changes
should be done by the advice mechanism. :-)
I'm not sure what should happen with the defun/advice/new defun
interaction you describe, I'll keep it in mind.
--
Institute of Policy and Planning Sciences http://turnbull.sk.tsukuba.ac.jp
University of Tsukuba Tennodai 1-1-1 Tsukuba 305-8573 JAPAN
Don't ask how you can "do" free software business;
ask what your business can "do for" free software.
8151
days inactive
8158
days old
6 comments
4 participants
participants (4)
-
Jeff Mincy -
Reuben Thomas -
Simon Josefsson -
Stephen J. Turnbull