11:05 a.m.
FYI, status of the mail-lib package visavi syncing it with FSF (which
is my goal with it).
File: Modifications compared to Emacs:
------------------------------------------------------
highlight-headers.el N/A (not part of Emacs).
mail-abbrevs.el N/A (not part of Emacs).
rmail-mini.el N/A (not part of Emacs).
base64.el None.
mailheader.el None.
rfc2104.el None.
rfc822.el None.
starttls.el None.
mail-utils.el Small. Weird QP stuff not in our version. XEmacs additions.
reporter.el Small. Due to 'rfc822-goto-eoh' missing in XEmacs.
browse-url.el [in progress]
rmailout.el [in progress]
mail-extr.el Medium.
smtpmail.el Medium. AUTH/STARTTLS support, MULE changes.
sendmail.el Large.
pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to xpop3.el?)
9:18 p.m.
Andy Piper <andyp(a)bea.com> writes:
At 12:05 PM 5/19/01 +0200, Simon Josefsson wrote:
>pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to xpop3.el?)
We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want to make
reasonable changes.
Note that the FSF *also* forked from the author's version.
10:05 p.m.
>>>> "Andy" == Andy Piper <andyp(a)bea.com>
writes:
Andy> At 12:05 PM 5/19/01 +0200, Simon Josefsson wrote:
> pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to xpop3.el?)
Andy> We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want to make
Andy> reasonable changes. I don't see why we should rename it.
gnus also includes pop3.el.
The xemacs.mak I contributed to gnus allows use of XEmacs mail-lib's
pop3.el by means of variable USE_XEMACS_MAIL_LIB.
Renaming our pop3.el would break that integration needlessly.
Best regards,
Adrian
Andy> abdy
--
Adrian Aichner
mailto:adrian＠xemacs.org
http://www.xemacs.org/
10:59 p.m.
Adrian.Aichner(a)t-online.de (Adrian Aichner) writes:
>> pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to
xpop3.el?)
Andy> We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want to make
Andy> reasonable changes. I don't see why we should rename it.
gnus also includes pop3.el.
...
Renaming our pop3.el would break that integration needlessly.
Yes, it was only a thought, only renaming it would be bad. But I felt
it wasn't perfect to have two (different) files with the same name.
(Which one will be used?)
Also, what about epop3? At least it shares some of the same function
names as mail-lib's pop3.el, and looks like it also share some of the
same features as mail-lib pop3 (UIDL etc). Also, there has actually
been a release of it recently (well, within the last 10 months).
11:21 p.m.
>>>> "Simon" == Simon Josefsson
<simon(a)josefsson.org> writes:
Simon> Adrian.Aichner(a)t-online.de (Adrian Aichner) writes:
> >> pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to
xpop3.el?)
>
Andy> We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want to
make
Andy> reasonable changes. I don't see why we should rename it.
>
> gnus also includes pop3.el.
Simon> ...
> Renaming our pop3.el would break that integration needlessly.
Simon> Yes, it was only a thought, only renaming it would be bad.
Simon> But I felt it wasn't perfect to have two (different) files
Simon> with the same name. (Which one will be used?)
Simon> Also, what about epop3? At least it shares some of the
Simon> same function names as mail-lib's pop3.el, and looks like
Simon> it also share some of the same features as mail-lib pop3
Simon> (UIDL etc). Also, there has actually been a release of it
Simon> recently (well, within the last 10 months).
Simon, I think Andy is our resident expert on pop3.
Right, Andy?
--
Adrian Aichner
mailto:adrian＠xemacs.org
http://www.xemacs.org/
9:22 a.m.
|--==> "APA" == Adrian Aichner <Adrian.Aichner(a)t-online.de> writes:
>>>>>"Andy" == Andy Piper
<andyp(a)bea.com> writes:
Andy> At 12:05 PM 5/19/01 +0200, Simon Josefsson
wrote:
>>pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to
xpop3.el?)
Andy> We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want to make
Andy> reasonable changes. I don't see why we should rename it.
APA> gnus also includes pop3.el.
APA> The xemacs.mak I contributed to gnus allows use of XEmacs mail-lib's
APA> pop3.el by means of variable USE_XEMACS_MAIL_LIB.
The mail-lib's pop3.el _is_ the Gnus one. Simon synced it a while back.
--
|---<Steve Youngs>---------------<GnuPG KeyID: 9E7E2820>---|
| XEmacs - It's not just an editor. |
| It's a way of life. |
|------------------------------------<youngs(a)xemacs.org>---|
10:20 a.m.
>>>> "SY" == Steve Youngs
<youngs(a)xemacs.org> writes:
SY> |--==> "APA" == Adrian Aichner <Adrian.Aichner(a)t-online.de>
writes:
>>>>>> "Andy" == Andy Piper
<andyp(a)bea.com> writes:
Andy> At 12:05 PM 5/19/01 +0200, Simon
Josefsson wrote:
>>> pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to
xpop3.el?)
Andy> We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want to make
Andy> reasonable changes. I don't see why we should rename it.
APA> gnus also includes pop3.el.
APA> The xemacs.mak I contributed to gnus allows use of XEmacs mail-lib's
APA> pop3.el by means of variable USE_XEMACS_MAIL_LIB.
SY> The mail-lib's pop3.el _is_ the Gnus one. Simon synced it a
SY> while back.
Oh, I missed that.
Anyway, mail-lib's pop3.el will be needed for users who don't have
gnus.
gnus may have incompatible changes in the future.
I guess my gnus/xemacs.mak logic is still applicable.
Do you disagree?
Adrian
SY> --
SY> |---<Steve Youngs>---------------<GnuPG KeyID: 9E7E2820>---|
SY> | XEmacs - It's not just an editor. |
SY> | It's a way of life. |
SY> |------------------------------------<youngs(a)xemacs.org>---|
--
Adrian Aichner
mailto:adrian＠xemacs.org
http://www.xemacs.org/
7:33 a.m.
>>>> "APA" == Adrian Aichner
<Adrian.Aichner(a)t-online.de> writes:
APA> gnus may have incompatible changes in the future.
Yup.
APA> I guess my gnus/xemacs.mak logic is still applicable.
It's true a name change would break it, but intentionally shadowing a
library is dangerous in any case. Even if it works, it makes
debugging harder for naive users. If there are other good reasons for
forking or recombining or whatever, it may be a good time to
reconsider that design.
Especially since there are now three or four versions of that
particular library (pop.el) floating around, not to mention extended
versions, any of which might end up in some user's ~/.xemacs/.
--
University of Tsukuba Tennodai 1-1-1 Tsukuba 305-8573 JAPAN
Institute of Policy and Planning Sciences Tel/fax: +81 (298) 53-5091
_________________ _________________ _________________ _________________
What are those straight lines for? "XEmacs rules."
10:36 a.m.
Steve Youngs <youngs(a)xemacs.org> writes:
Andy> We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want
to make
Andy> reasonable changes. I don't see why we should rename it.
APA> gnus also includes pop3.el.
APA> The xemacs.mak I contributed to gnus allows use of XEmacs mail-lib's
APA> pop3.el by means of variable USE_XEMACS_MAIL_LIB.
The mail-lib's pop3.el _is_ the Gnus one. Simon synced it a while back.
No, pop3.el in mail-lib is not the same as in Gnus -- the one in
mail-lib got oodles of useful stuff not in the original pop3.el file.
Oh, I just now noticed the pop3.el shipped with Gnus is not in the
XEmacs gnus package. I guess the mail-lib pop3.el is backwards
compatible then.
9:46 p.m.
At 11:36 AM 5/20/01 +0200, Simon Josefsson wrote:
Oh, I just now noticed the pop3.el shipped with Gnus is not in the
XEmacs gnus package. I guess the mail-lib pop3.el is backwards
compatible then.
That in fact was the motivation - I wanted a drop-in replacement for the
GNUS version that support UIDL.
andy
10:22 p.m.
>>>> "Andy" == Andy Piper <andyp(a)bea.com>
writes:
Andy> At 11:36 AM 5/20/01 +0200, Simon Josefsson wrote:
> Oh, I just now noticed the pop3.el shipped with Gnus is not in
the
> XEmacs gnus package. I guess the mail-lib pop3.el is backwards
> compatible then.
Andy> That in fact was the motivation - I wanted a drop-in
Andy> replacement for the GNUS version that support UIDL.
Yes, I remember testing your new UIDL support.
I just love reading my mail on Windows using XEmacs/Gnus/mail-lib from
a local UNIX server via pop3.
That way I can avoid Lotus Notes + Domino Bricks.
Adrian
Andy> andy
--
Adrian Aichner
mailto:adrian＠xemacs.org
http://www.xemacs.org/
9:44 p.m.
At 06:22 PM 5/20/01 +1000, Steve Youngs wrote:
|--==> "APA" == Adrian Aichner
<Adrian.Aichner(a)t-online.de> writes:
>>>>>>"Andy" == Andy Piper <andyp(a)bea.com> writes:
Andy> At 12:05 PM 5/19/01 +0200, Simon Josefsson wrote:
>>>pop3.el Heavy modifications. (Rename to xpop3.el?)
Andy> We forked from the FSF because the author didn't want to make
Andy> reasonable changes. I don't see why we should rename it.
APA> gnus also includes pop3.el.
APA> The xemacs.mak I contributed to gnus allows use of XEmacs mail-lib's
APA> pop3.el by means of variable USE_XEMACS_MAIL_LIB.
The mail-lib's pop3.el _is_ the Gnus one. Simon synced it a while back.
Well, if that's true the GNUS people must have adopted my version because
its still got the stuff I added.
andy
8399
days inactive
8401
days old
12 comments
6 participants
participants (6)
-
Adrian Aichner -
Andy Piper -
Hrvoje Niksic -
Simon Josefsson -
Stephen J. Turnbull -
Steve Youngs