Rick Campbell writes:
Date: Sun, 3 Jan 1999 12:32:03 -0800 (PST)
From: Martin Buchholz <martin(a)xemacs.org>
In tty mode, and by default in X mode, the block cursor covers the
character after point. What could be more intuitive behavior than
having the key labelled Del delete that character?
Your question may be rhetorical, but my answer is ``leaving things
alone.''
For better or worse, users are arriving with different expectations
than the old UNIX community. It isn't the fault of these users that
they think this way. DEC and minicomputers and dumb terminals were
a mainstay of our indoctrination into the profession. Microsoft and
desktop PCs are a mainstay of theirs.
I agree with a later remark in your message that neither behavior
of the DEL key is more obvious than the other. The problem is
that we have two different communities that we are trying to
serve.
We could take the political stance than the Windows community is
a closed, market driven community which has done nothing to
improve our community, that being the free software community.
And using this reasoning, we could refuse to support them and
their UI assumptions. After all, we have limited amounts of
resources and time and those resources should be spent building
up our own community. This is, in a nutshell, my point of view.
But with the broadening acceptance of open source products, I'm
beginning to see that leaning a little toward the enemy might
further our cause in the long term. We can obviously thank the
explosion of the Internet for opening those corporate eyes, as
no one could miss that the application layer of the Internet is
thoroughly infested with open source software. But if we want
to keep the attention of rest of the world, we have to bend a
little. Fiddling with the DEL key is pretty minor in the grand
scheme of things. If it will keep otherwise interested people
from disgustedly closing their minds to open source solutions,
then it is worth it. We don't have many advertising dollars to
convince people, so we'll have to persaude them a few at a time.
So yeah, I'm framing the issue in a way that makes us into noble
Messiahs. It lets me sleep at night. :)