case-table braindamage

I have just been trying to do something very simple which should most easily be achieved by installing a temporary case table. (The task is to enter "a" in isearch, and find "áàÁÀ" etc as well as "A".) Having discovered that this doesn't work my in my very old 21.4.12 (in a bizarre way: searching for, e.g. "e" does find "é", but searching for "se" does not find "sé"), I thought I might as well go to 21.5 as to the latest 21.4. (I've just found that it was fixed by 21.4.20, but never mind.) So I moved to 21.5.28. It worked - eventually. The problem here was that the temporary case table was installed, but not uninstalled at the end of the search - and moreover, the standard case table was now the temporary one. After much tearing of hair, I read casetab.c carefully, and saw the following bizarre fact: set_case_tab does what you expect when given a genuine C case_table object: it changes either Vstandard_case_table or buf->case_table to be the argument. *However*, if given the case table data as (up to) four strings, it doesn't do this: instead it modifies the existing case table (standard or buffer) in place. Hence if a buffer has the standard case table, setting the buffer case table also sets the standard. I can just about imagine that one might want to do this with the standard case table (though the documentation says that the standard case table applies to *new* buffers), but the other way???? What's even odder is that this behaviour has got worse. In 21.4, a buffer case table is at least dealt with as you would expect - a new case table is allocated, modified according to the string data, and made the buffer table - but the standard case table is modified in place. In 21.5(.28), both are modified in place. Why? This behaviour seems utterly at odds with what one would expect from functions called "set-", rather than "modify-". _______________________________________________ XEmacs-Beta mailing list XEmacs-Beta(a)xemacs.org http://calypso.tux.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/xemacs-beta