Rick Campbell <rick(a)campbellcentral.org> writes:
[1. text/plain]
From: Hrvoje Niksic <hniksic(a)srce.hr>
Date: 14 Oct 1998 11:23:49 +0200
Rick Campbell <rick(a)campbellcentral.org> writes:
> I still believe that an FSF suit against Microsoft would be a
> joke.
Why do you think so? The NeXT did quit.
I'm not understanding you. What do you mean by ``The NeXT did
quit.'' -- I'm assuming that you refer to a lawsuit of which I'm not
aware.
I am referring to the incident when NeXT created an ObjC backend for
Gcc and wanted to distribute binaries only. FSF threatened to sue,
and NeXT gave in, apparently because their lawyers informed them that
they would lose the lawsuit. As a result, Gcc now supports ObjC.
Although this incident is in no way equivalent to being tested in
court, I consider it a compliment to the legal strength of the GPL.
This is also how I envision an argument between FSF and Microsoft --
noone goes to court unless they feel they can win.
If your statement involves relating NeXT to Microsoft in terms of
power and size, I'll argue against that point of view.
There's nothing to argue against. I'm just describing what happened
in a real-life case when GPL was threatened by a corporation. I
concede that with Microsoft things could turn out for the worse.
In any case, I think that a lawsuit by FSF against Microsoft would
be a joke because I'm cynical enough to think that money and power
are bigger factors in determining outcome than being in the right.
Maybe. I don't know.
--
Hrvoje Niksic <hniksic(a)srce.hr> | Student at FER Zagreb, Croatia
--------------------------------+--------------------------------
Call CIA and tell them that you have placed a bomb in a 7-11 shop! Be
sure to let them trace you. Spend 10 years in jail and then regret it.